top of page
Search

PEO Pricing Explained: Per-Employee Fees vs. Percent of Payroll

edgriffin81
Nov 7
2 min read

"What does a PEO cost?" is one of the first questions owners ask, and one of the hardest to answer from a single quote. PEOs price their services in different ways, and the way a quote is built can make two very different deals look alike.


Here's how PEO pricing works, what drives the total, and how to compare quotes fairly.


The three common pricing models


  • Per employee per month (PEPM). A flat admin fee for each employee, each month. Easy to understand and easy to budget. Taxes, workers' comp, and benefits are usually billed separately.

  • Percent of payroll. The admin fee is a percentage of total wages. It grows as your payroll grows, including raises, overtime, and bonuses, so the same service can cost more each year.

  • Bundled pricing. Admin fees, workers' comp, and sometimes taxes are rolled into one rate. Simple on the invoice, but harder to see what you're paying for each piece.


None of these is automatically better. What matters is how they compare for your headcount, your payroll, and your industry.


What actually drives your total PEO cost


The admin fee gets the most attention, but it's usually not the biggest number on the invoice. Your total cost is made up of:


  • Benefits. Often the largest line. Plan design, carrier, and how your renewals have trended matter more than almost anything else.

  • Workers' comp. Driven by your class codes, industry, and claims history. Small classification errors can add up.

  • Payroll taxes and SUI. Some PEOs report under their own state unemployment account and others under yours. The difference can change your rate.

  • Admin fee. Important, but only one piece of the total.


How to compare PEO quotes fairly


To compare PEO pricing, put every quote on the same basis: same employees, same wages, same benefit elections, and the full annual cost including benefits, workers' comp, and taxes. Then look past price to service, technology, and fit. We cover this in more detail in How to Compare PEO Quotes.


Already with a PEO?


If you're already with a PEO, the question isn't just what a PEO costs. It's whether your PEO is still priced right for your business today. A free PEO benchmark shows where you stand, so you can stay, renegotiate, or switch with confidence.


I'm an independent PEO broker, so I'm not tied to any one provider. There's no cost to you for the review, and no obligation to change anything.


 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page